With dozens of spare tire cover designs in the catalog, the easiest way to narrow it down is to see what other Jeep owners actually bought and rated. This list ranks the 10 most-reviewed spare tire covers at Jeep Decal Store by customer review count, with star ratings included so you can see which ones earned the strongest responses. All are made from UV-rated polyester nylon weave, available in sizes from 27 to 35 inches, with backup camera hole options for JL and JK Wranglers.
How These Rankings Work
Each cover below is ranked by total customer reviews, highest first. Ties are broken by star rating. Covers with zero reviews were not included regardless of how new or popular they are by sales. This is a snapshot of what customers have actually reviewed, not an editorial pick list.
1. Design Your Own Custom Personalized Spare Tire Cover
17 reviews · 4.76 stars
The most-reviewed cover in the catalog and the one with the strongest overall rating. Customers bring their own photo, logo, artwork, or text and it gets printed as a full-color digital graphic directly on the polyester nylon weave cover. Every print is one of a kind. Available in all standard Jeep spare tire sizes with a backup camera hole option for vehicles that need it.
Your photo, logo, or design printed on UV-rated polyester nylon weave. Camera hole option available.
2. Black Shadowed Norse Tree of Life Spare Tire Cover
10 reviews · 3.5 stars
The second most-reviewed design in the catalog. The shadowed art treatment gives the Yggdrasil tree a darker, more dramatic silhouette compared to the classic colored version. A popular choice for Jeep owners drawn to Norse mythology with a moodier, less colorful aesthetic. One of two Tree of Life designs in the top 3.
Dark silhouette Yggdrasil design on polyester nylon weave. Camera hole option available.
3. Norse Tree of Life Spare Tire Cover
6 reviews · 5.0 stars
A perfect 5.0 average across 6 reviews makes this the highest-rated design with more than 2 reviews. The original colorful version of the Yggdrasil tree, rendered in mystical blues and gold. If you want the Tree of Life with full color rather than the dark shadowed treatment, this is the one.
Full-color Yggdrasil in blue and gold on UV-rated polyester nylon weave. Camera hole option available.
4. Have the Day You Deserve Peace Skeleton Spare Tire Cover
2 reviews · 4.5 stars
A humorous and slightly edgy design: a skeleton throwing up peace signs against a dark background. It reads clearly from a distance and gets reactions from other drivers. A good pick for Jeep owners who want personality on the back of the rig without going full Halloween.
Skeleton with peace signs on a dark background. Bold and readable from a distance.
5. Funny Cat Ring Spare Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
A ring of cats arranged in a circular pattern that fills the cover from edge to edge. The circular format of a spare tire cover is a natural fit for this kind of radial design. A quirky and charming pick that tends to stop people in parking lots.
Ring of cats in a radial design built for the circular cover format. Camera hole option available.
6. Halloween Spooky Spider Web Spare Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
A gothic spider web design that works for Halloween season but also fits year-round for Jeep owners who lean toward dark or edgy aesthetics. The web radiates outward from the center in a way that complements the tire cover's circular shape naturally.
Gothic web design that radiates from the center. Works for Halloween or year-round dark builds.
7. Camera Aperture Lens Spare Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
A photorealistic camera aperture printed on the cover. The concentric blades of the lens opening make it one of the more technically detailed designs in the catalog. A particularly fitting pick if your Jeep has the backup camera hole option: the lens cutout sits at the center of the aperture design exactly where a real lens would be.
Photorealistic aperture design. The camera hole cutout lines up with the lens center.
8. AstroMech Navigator Droid Spare Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
The R2-D2 style astromech droid in full color, one of the more visually detailed sci-fi designs in the collection. The circular shape of the cover mirrors the droid's dome, and the design is recognizable at a glance. A consistent conversation piece for Jeep owners who are also into sci-fi.
Full-color astromech droid design on UV-rated polyester nylon weave. Camera hole option available.
9. Halloween Faux Quilted Stitch Pumpkin Patch Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
A quilted patchwork-style Halloween cover with pumpkins and fall tones. The faux-stitch effect gives it the look of a handmade textile, which is unusual among tire cover designs and sets it apart from standard illustrated Halloween covers. Subtle enough for early fall, bold enough for Halloween season.
Faux-stitch quilted pumpkin design with fall tones. Subtle for early fall, bold for Halloween season.
10. Forest Moon Expeditions Spare Tire Cover
1 review · 5.0 stars
A wilderness and celestial design with an outdoor adventure feel. The typography and scenic composition give it the look of a vintage expedition patch, which works well on trail-focused Jeep builds. A more understated choice compared to the graphic-heavy designs higher on this list.
Vintage expedition patch aesthetic with a celestial and wilderness theme. Good for trail-focused builds.
Frequently asked questions
What size spare tire cover do I need for my Jeep?
Tire cover sizing is based on the outside diameter of your mounted spare, not the tire designation alone. Most Jeep Wranglers and Gladiators run covers in the 30 to 33 inch range. Check your tire sidewall for the size (e.g., 265/70R17 is about 30.6 inches outside diameter; 285/70R17 is about 32.7 inches). If you're between sizes, size up. Our tire cover size guide walks through the measurement in detail.
Do I need a backup camera hole?
If your Jeep has a backup camera mounted on the spare tire carrier, yes. Most JL Wranglers have one from the factory, and many JK Wranglers do as well. Look for a small round lens at the center of your tailgate or spare tire carrier. If it's there, order the camera hole version. If there's no camera, the standard cover (no hole) is the right choice.
What material are these tire covers made from?
All JDS spare tire covers are made from UV-rated polyester nylon weave with full-color digital printing. The material is water-resistant, stays flexible in cold weather, and is rated for years of direct outdoor UV exposure. See our full material breakdown in the tire cover material guide.
How do I care for a spare tire cover?
Mild soap and water with a soft cloth. Avoid pressure washers and harsh chemical cleaners, which degrade the UV-resistant print coating over time. Remove the cover and wash it flat when needed, then let it air dry fully before reinstalling to prevent moisture trapping between the cover and tire.
Can I get a fully custom design not on this list?
Yes. The #1 cover on this list is the custom design option: bring your own photo, logo, text, or artwork and it gets printed on the same UV-rated polyester nylon weave as every other cover in the catalog. Camera hole and all size options are available on custom orders. Start your custom order here.
Ready to find your design? Browse the full selection: Custom Spare Tire Covers for Jeep.
0 comments